NOTE: This Problem Requires Present Value Information As an Analyst You Wish to Restate Charter’s Operating Leases

question 38

Essay

NOTE: This problem requires present value information.
Charter Corp. manufactures office equipment and supplies throughout the U.S. The company owns property, plant, and equipment and also enters into operating leases for certain facilities. The company's tax rate is 35%. Listed below is selected financial data for Charter and the company's operating lease disclosure.
$\begin{array}{lll}&2012&2011&2010\\\text { Property, Plant, \& Equipment (net) } & \$ 178,454 & \$ 162,369 &\$155,388\\\text { Total Assets } & 515,685 & 424,545&410,256 \\\text { Common Shareholders'Equity } & 302,754 & 298,564&289,455 \\\\\text { Sales } & \$ 986,258&\$888,965\\\text { Cost of GoodsSold } &693,857 & 588,920 \\\text { Depreciation Expense } & \\\text { Interest Expense } &84.253 & 75,689 \\\text { Net Income } & 124,581&91,025\\\end{array}$ $\begin{array}{|l|l|}\hline & \text { Charter Corp. } \\\hline & \text { Operating Lease Disclosure } \\\hline & \text { (amounts in thousands) } \\\hline & \\\hline & \text { Operating Lease Comunitments } \\\hline & \text { at the end of } 2012 \\\hline & \\\hline & \\\hline \text { Year } & \text { Reported Lease Comumitments } \\\hline 2013 & \$ 25,239 \\\hline 2014 & \$ 52,800 \\\hline 2015 & \$ 78,924 \\\hline 2016 & \$ 48,760 \\\hline 2017 & \$ 45,678 \\\hline \text { Bevond } 2017 & \$ 212,000 \\\hline\end{array}$

As an analyst you wish to restate Charter’s operating leases into capital leases.

Required:
a. Using the information in the operating lease disclosure, and assuming that Charter has an incremental borrowing rate for secured debt of 8%, restate the operating leases into capital leases.
b. Estimate the average life of the operating leases.
c. Calculate Charter’s fixed asset turnover ratio as reported.
d. Would Charter’s fixed asset turnover ratio increase or decrease, assuming that the operating leases were capitalized?

---

Definitions:

Chronic Diseases

Long-term medical conditions that are persistent or otherwise long-lasting in their effects and often require ongoing management or treatment.

Anticipatory Grief

The grief experienced prior to an impending loss, such as the anticipated death of a loved one.

Support Group

A gathering of individuals who share common experiences or conditions, offering each other emotional and moral support.

Peak of the Pangs

The highest or most intense point of emotional or physical suffering.