Describe the Manner by Which Justices Are Appointed to and Retain

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Justices are appointed to the Supreme Court by the President of the United States and must be confirmed by the Senate. Once appointed, they serve for life unless they choose to retire or are impeached and removed from office. This procedure has been criticized as undemocratic because it allows a small group of individuals to have significant influence over the makeup of the Court for many years. However, it can also be seen as a necessary curb to democratic excesses, as it insulates the Court from the whims of popular opinion and allows justices to make decisions based on the Constitution and the law rather than political pressure.

As for the selection of justices, there is a debate over whether they should be openly selected on the basis of their ideological stances or if the president and the Senate should strive to find well-informed but impartial candidates. Some argue that openly selecting justices based on their ideological stances would make the process more transparent and allow for a more honest discussion of the Court's role in shaping public policy. Others believe that justices should be impartial and make decisions based on the law rather than their personal beliefs.

Ultimately, the appointment and retention of Supreme Court justices is a complex and contentious issue that involves balancing the need for an independent judiciary with the desire for transparency and accountability. It is a topic that will continue to be debated and reevaluated as the role of the Court in American society evolves.

Describe the Manner by Which Justices Are Appointed to and Retain

Definitions: