Why Do Cases Go to Trial

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Cases go to trial for several reasons, primarily when legal disputes cannot be resolved through pre-trial negotiations or alternative dispute resolution methods such as mediation or arbitration. Here are some of the key reasons why cases may end up going to trial:

1. **Disputed Facts**: When the parties involved in a case disagree on the facts, a trial becomes necessary for a fact-finder (judge or jury) to determine what actually happened. Each side presents evidence and witness testimony to support their version of events.

2. **Disputed Law**: Sometimes, the facts may be agreed upon, but the parties disagree on how the law applies to those facts. A trial provides a formal setting for legal arguments to be made and for a judge to interpret and apply the law to the case at hand.

3. **No Settlement Reached**: Often, parties try to avoid the expense and uncertainty of a trial by negotiating a settlement. However, if they cannot agree on the terms of a settlement, the case will go to trial for a resolution.

4. **Justice and Public Interest**: Some cases go to trial because the parties seek a public verdict, either for reasons of justice (such as in criminal cases where society's interest is at stake) or to set a legal precedent. Public trials can also bring attention to important social issues.

5. **Strategic Reasons**: In some instances, one or both parties may believe they have a strong case and that going to trial will result in a more favorable outcome than a settlement. They may also believe that the process of going to trial will bring forth more evidence or weaken the other side's position.

6. **Jury Sympathy**: Some cases, particularly those involving personal stories or emotional elements, may be taken to trial in the hope that a jury will be more sympathetic and award a more favorable verdict than a judge during pre-trial negotiations.

7. **Enforceable Judgments**: A trial verdict can lead to an enforceable judgment. If one party is seeking a definitive court order that can be enforced by law, such as an injunction or specific performance, a trial may be necessary.

8. **Complexity**: Some cases are too complex to be settled out of court. They may involve multiple parties, complex legal issues, or significant amounts of money, making it difficult to reach a settlement that satisfies everyone involved.

9. **Principle or Precedent**: Sometimes, parties are motivated by principle or the desire to set a legal precedent. They may feel that going to trial is important to stand up for their rights or to influence the development of the law.

10. **Mandatory Trials**: Certain types of cases, like most criminal cases, are not eligible for settlement and must go to trial. The right to a trial is often guaranteed by law to ensure that justice is served.

In summary, cases go to trial when parties cannot resolve their differences outside of court, when they seek a formal legal judgment, or when they wish to have their dispute resolved in a public forum. Trials are an essential component of the legal system, providing a structured environment for the adjudication of disputes and the enforcement of legal rights.

Why Do Cases Go to Trial

Definitions: