McKesson HBOC Restates Revenue

question 63

Essay

McKesson HBOC Restates Revenue

McKesson Corporation, the nation’s largest drug wholesaler, acquired medical software provider HBO & Co. in a $14.1 billion stock deal in early 1999. The transaction was touted as having created the country’s largest comprehensive health care services company. McKesson had annual sales of $18.1 billion in fiscal year 1998, and HBO & Co. had fiscal 1998 revenue of $1.2 billion. HBO & Co. makes information systems that include clinical, financial, billing, physician practice, and medical records software. Charles W. McCall, the chair, president, and chief executive of HBO & Co., was named the new chair of McKesson HBOC.

As one of the decade’s hottest stocks, it had soared 38-fold since early 1992. McKesson’s first attempt to acquire HBO in mid-1998 collapsed following a news leak. However, McKesson’s persistence culminated in a completed transaction in January 1999. In its haste, McKesson closed the deal even before an in-depth audit of HBO’s books had been completed. In fact, the audit did not begin until after the close of the 1999 fiscal year. McKesson was so confident that its auditing firm, Deloitte & Touche, would not find anything that it released unaudited results that included the impact of HBO shortly after the close of the 1999 fiscal year on March 31, 1999. Within days, indications that contracts had been backdated began to surface.

By May, McKesson hired forensic accountants skilled at reconstructing computer records. By early June, the accountants were able to reconstruct deleted computer files, which revealed a list of improperly recorded contracts. This evidence underscored HBO’s efforts to deliberately accelerate revenues by backdating contracts that were not final. Moreover, HBO shipped software to customers that they had not ordered, while knowing that it would be returned. In doing so, they were able to boost reported earnings, the company’s share price, and ultimately the purchase price paid by McKesson.

In mid-July, McKesson announced that it would have to reduce revenue by $327 million and net income by $191.5 million for the past 3 fiscal years to correct for accounting irregularities. The company’s stock had fallen by 48% since late April when it first announced that it would have to restate earnings. McKesson’s senior management had to contend with rebuilding McKesson’s reputation, resolving more than 50 lawsuits, and attempting to recover $9.5 billion in market value lost since the need to restate earnings was first announced. When asked how such a thing could happen, McKesson spokespeople said they were intentionally kept from the due diligence process before the transaction closed. Despite not having adequate access to HBO’s records, McKesson decided to close the transaction anyway.
-Assume an audit had been conducted and HBO's financial statements had been declared to be in accordance with GAAP. Would McKesson have been justified in believing that HBO's revenue and profit figures were 100% accurate?

---

Definitions:

Bolus

A small rounded mass of a substance, especially of chewed food at the moment of swallowing.

Esophagus

The part of the digestive tract that conducts food from the pharynx to the stomach.

Amylase

An enzyme that catalyzes the hydrolysis of starch into sugars, present in saliva and pancreatic fluid.

Starch

A carbohydrate consisting of a large number of glucose units joined by glycosidic bonds, primarily found in plants and used as an energy store.