If Two Logicians Are Distilling the Same Extended Argument, Is

question 107

Multiple Choice

If two logicians are distilling the same extended argument, is it possible that they would arrange the propositions into two different forms?

• A)Yes, because how the propositions are arranged is completely unimportant.
• B)Yes, but only if one logician is better at logic than the other.
• C)Yes, because there could be more than one good way to proceed through the argument.
• D)No, because there is only one correct way to arrange the propositions in any particular argument.
• E)No, because those forms would necessarily have different conclusions, and therefore not be forms of the same argument.

---

Definitions:

Structural Holes

Social network gaps between individuals or groups that provide opportunities for those who can bridge these gaps to access diverse information or resources, thereby gaining advantages.

Greater Access

An increased availability or ease of obtaining resources, information, or services, often improving opportunity and choice.

Political Savvy

The ability to understand and navigate organizational politics and power dynamics effectively.

Political Power

The ability to influence or outright control the behavior of people and institutions, often within a governmental or organizational context.