How Does Extinction in Neglect Provide Evidence for Competition

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Extinction in neglect is a phenomenon observed in patients with unilateral neglect, typically after damage to one hemisphere of the brain, most commonly the right hemisphere. Unilateral neglect is a condition where patients fail to attend to stimuli on the side opposite the brain lesion (the left side in the case of right hemisphere damage). Extinction is a specific symptom of neglect where a patient can detect a stimulus presented on the neglected side when it is presented alone, but fails to detect it when another stimulus is presented simultaneously on the non-neglected side.

The concept of extinction in neglect provides evidence for the competition theory because it suggests that stimuli presented to both sides of space are in competition for neural representation and attentional resources. When two stimuli are presented, one on each side, the stimulus on the non-neglected side (the right side for patients with right hemisphere damage) wins the competition for attention, and the stimulus on the neglected side (the left side) is not processed or is processed but not attended to.

This competitive dynamic is supported by the fact that when the stimulus on the neglected side is presented alone, without competition from the other side, the patient can often detect it. This indicates that the sensory apparatus for detecting the stimulus on the neglected side is still functional, but that the attentional system is biased towards the non-neglected side, especially when there is competition from stimuli presented there.

The competition theory is further supported by neuroimaging and neurophysiological studies that show activation in attentional networks of the brain when stimuli are presented to both sides. These studies suggest that there is a neural basis for the competition between stimuli for attentional resources.

In summary, extinction in neglect provides evidence for competition in attentional processing because it demonstrates that when two stimuli are presented simultaneously, one on each side of space, they compete for attention, and the stimulus on the non-neglected side typically wins this competition, leading to the neglect of the stimulus on the opposite side. This phenomenon highlights the competitive nature of attentional selection and the limited capacity of the attentional system to process multiple stimuli at once.

How Does Extinction in Neglect Provide Evidence for Competition

Definitions: