A Behavioural Neuroscientist Wishes to Study the Potential of a New

question 14

Multiple Choice

A behavioural neuroscientist wishes to study the potential of a new technology for restoring vision in people with damage to a specific region of the brain.Neuropsychologists have already done work with humans who have damage to that region and their results are encouraging but the number of people available for testing is too small to make definitive conclusions.The researcher proposes testing the effect of the technology on monkeys.In order to do that test she has to damage part of the brain of the monkeys and then check if the technology restores vision.A protest group forms outside the laboratory where the research is being conducted.The leader of the protest volunteers to submit to the brain damaging intervention and treatment if the monkeys can be saved.Which of the following statements is true?

• A)The researcher should definitely take up the offer.
• B)The researcher should take up the offer but only if the protest ends.
• C)The researcher should take up the offer but only if they are sure that the treatment works.
• D)The researcher should not take up the offer unless the ethics committee orders it.
• E)Not enough information has been supplied to answer this question, but, on its own, simply replacing animal participants with willing humans could never address all relevant ethical issues.

---

Definitions:

Rights and Responsibilities

Fundamental ethical and legal entitlements paired with duties or obligations that individuals in a society possess.

Defamation

The process of making untrue remarks about someone that harm their good name.

Civil Law

Civil law is a branch of law dealing with disputes between individuals or organizations, typically involving compensation for damages or enforcement of contracts, as opposed to criminal law.

Public Law

The area of law that governs the relationship between individuals and the state, including constitutional, administrative, and criminal law.