Distinguish Between Disguised and Undisguised Observation

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Disguised and undisguised observation are two different methods used in research, particularly in the fields of social sciences, marketing, and psychology, to collect data about subjects' behavior. The key difference between the two lies in whether the subjects are aware that they are being observed.

Disguised Observation:
In disguised observation, the subjects are unaware that they are being observed. The observer remains hidden or camouflaged, or the observation is conducted in such a way that the presence of the observer is not noticeable. This method is used to ensure that the behavior of the subjects is natural and unaffected by the observer's presence. Disguised observation can be conducted using hidden cameras, one-way mirrors, or by having the observer pose as a member of the group being studied.

Advantages of disguised observation include the following:
- It reduces the Hawthorne effect, where subjects alter their behavior because they know they are being observed.
- It allows for the collection of data on natural, spontaneous behaviors.

However, there are also ethical considerations with disguised observation, as it involves observing people without their consent. Researchers must ensure that their studies comply with ethical guidelines and that the privacy and rights of the subjects are respected.

Undisguised Observation:
In undisguised observation, the subjects are aware that they are being observed. This can happen in a natural setting where the observer is visible, or in a controlled environment like a laboratory or a focus group facility. Subjects may be informed about the observation beforehand, or they may quickly become aware of the observer's presence.

Advantages of undisguised observation include the following:
- It is ethically transparent, as subjects are aware of the observation and can give informed consent.
- It can be easier to implement, as it does not require the observer to hide or use covert methods.

However, the main disadvantage is that subjects may change their behavior because they know they are being watched, a phenomenon known as reactivity. This can lead to less authentic data.

In summary, the choice between disguised and undisguised observation depends on the research goals, the importance of observing natural behavior, ethical considerations, and the potential impact of the observer's presence on the subjects' behavior. Researchers must carefully consider these factors when designing their studies to ensure that they collect valid and reliable data while respecting the rights and privacy of the subjects.

Distinguish Between Disguised and Undisguised Observation

Definitions: