Critical Thinking: Billy Is Driving Home from a Bar on a Friday

question 49

Multiple Choice

Critical Thinking:
Billy is driving home from a bar on a Friday night when he comes upon a DUI checkpoint. At the checkpoint, an officer smells alcohol on Billy's breath and asks him to step out of the car. Billy stumbles out of the car and slurs his words when asked a few basic questions about who he is and where he is going. Billy refuses to consent to a breathalyzer, but the officer does have a video camera record Billy as he is stumbling and slurring his words. Billy is arrested on suspicion of DUI and taken to the police station. At the station, a sample of Billy's blood is taken. Although Billy does not consent to this, he is too drunk to put up much resistance. At his trial, officers play a video of Billy slurring his words and also introduce the blood evidence. He is convicted of DUI.
-Had this checkpoint a "drug checkpoint" instead of a DUI checkpoint, then which statement would be true?

• A) Case law indicates that appellate courts would have upheld the use of this checkpoint as well as Billy's arrest for DUI.
• B) Case law indicates that appellate courts would have upheld the general use of a "drug checkpoint," but Billy's conviction would be overturned because he did not have any drugs.
• C) Case law indicates that appellate courts would disapprove of a "drug checkpoint" and would also overturn a DUI conviction stemming from a stop at a "drug checkpoint".
• D) None of these statements are true.

---

Definitions:

Comparative Advantage

The ability of an individual, company, or country to produce a good or service at a lower opportunity cost than competitors, leading to specialized production and trade benefits.

Geegaws

Inexpensive, showy trinkets or novelty items.

Doodads

Informal term for small, often decorative objects with no specific utility or function.

Type Alpha Employees

A categorization for employees who are highly motivated, confident, and capable of independent work.