Compare and Contrast Proportional Representation and the Plurality/majority Systems of Voting.In

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Proportional representation and the plurality/majority systems of voting are two different methods of electing representatives in a democratic system.

In a plurality/majority system, the candidate with the most votes in a single-member district wins the election. This system often leads to a two-party system, as smaller parties have a difficult time gaining representation. It can also result in a discrepancy between the percentage of votes a party receives and the percentage of seats they win in the legislature.

On the other hand, proportional representation aims to allocate seats in the legislature in proportion to the percentage of votes each party receives. This allows for a more diverse representation of political parties and can result in a more accurate reflection of the electorate's preferences. However, it can also lead to more coalition governments and potentially less stable governance.

In my view, the best system for Canada would be a mixed-member proportional representation system. This system combines elements of both proportional representation and the plurality/majority system, allowing for a balance between local representation and proportionality. It would ensure that smaller parties are not marginalized while still maintaining a connection between constituents and their elected representatives. This system has been successful in countries like Germany and New Zealand and could be a good fit for Canada's diverse political landscape.

Compare and Contrast Proportional Representation and the Plurality/majority Systems of Voting.In

Definitions: