Consider the Implications of the Ethical Problem Presented by the Utilitarian

question 7

Essay

Consider the implications of the ethical problem presented by the utilitarian logic behind deterrence-that it "doesn't matter who you punish," even when you are talking about capital punishment. Whether they are guilty or not, it "only matters that you punish someone." Discuss.

---

Definitions:

Implanted Pulse Generator

A medical device surgically placed in the body to deliver electrical pulses to specific areas, often used to treat chronic pain or neurological disorders.

Deep Brain Stimulation

A medical treatment involving the implantation of a device that sends electrical impulses to specific parts of the brain to treat various neurological conditions.

Vagus Nerve Stimulation

A treatment procedure for depression in which an implanted pulse generator sends regular electrical signals to a person’s vagus nerve; the nerve, in turn, stimulates the brain.

ECT

Electroconvulsive Therapy is a mental health treatment where seizures are deliberately triggered in patients using electrical currents to alleviate symptoms of mental illnesses.