Why Was the So-Called Auburn System Eventually Adopted in the United

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The so-called Auburn system, also known as the New York or congregate system, was a penal method of the 19th century that was eventually adopted in the United States due to its perceived benefits over alternative prison models, particularly the Pennsylvania system. The Auburn system was named after the Auburn Prison in New York, where the approach was first implemented.

Several factors contributed to the adoption of the Auburn system:

1. **Economic Efficiency**: The Auburn system allowed for prisoners to work together in silence during the day, which made it possible for prisons to operate workshops and produce goods. This was seen as a way to make prisons more economically self-sufficient and reduce the cost of incarceration for the state.

2. **Discipline and Order**: The system emphasized strict discipline, with a regimented schedule and enforced silence. Prisoners were expected to work in groups but were prohibited from communicating with each other, which was believed to prevent the spread of criminal ideas and maintain order within the prison.

3. **Rehabilitation**: Although the Auburn system was strict, it was also believed to offer a chance at rehabilitation. The combination of labor, discipline, and moral instruction was thought to instill habits of industry and improve the character of inmates.

4. **Overcrowding**: The Pennsylvania system, which was the main alternative at the time, required solitary confinement for each inmate, which necessitated larger facilities and was more expensive to build and maintain. As the prison population grew, the Auburn system's more efficient use of space became a significant advantage.

5. **Practicality**: The Auburn system was seen as more practical and easier to implement on a large scale. It required fewer guards and less complex facilities than the Pennsylvania system, which needed individual cells large enough for inmates to live and work in isolation.

6. **Social Control**: The Auburn system's strict regime of silence and group labor was also seen as a means of social control, reinforcing the power of the state over the individual and serving as a deterrent to crime.

Despite its adoption and the perceived advantages, the Auburn system was not without its critics. The enforced silence and lack of social interaction were seen by some as cruel and detrimental to the mental health of prisoners. Over time, the system evolved, and many of its harsher aspects were mitigated or abandoned in favor of more progressive correctional strategies. However, the influence of the Auburn system can still be seen in the emphasis on work and discipline in many modern correctional institutions.

Why Was the So-Called Auburn System Eventually Adopted in the United

Definitions: