Consider a Judge Who Must Determine Whether a 16-Year-Old Who

question 42

Essay

Consider a judge who must determine whether a 16-year-old who committed a violent crime should be tried as an adult. Identify the ethical dilemma(s)the judge faces and describe how she might arrive at an ethical decision.

---

Definitions:

Aids

Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome, a chronic, potentially life-threatening condition caused by the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), which severely damages the immune system.

Type A Personality

A personality type characterized by a constant feeling of working against the clock and a strong sense of competition.

Irritable

Characterizes a state or condition of being easily annoyed or made angry.

Impatient

Characterized by a tendency to be easily annoyed or eager for immediate action or results.