What Is the Argument in Support of Torture? What Is

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The argument in support of torture is often based on the belief that it can be an effective means of obtaining information from individuals who may have critical knowledge that could prevent harm or save lives. Proponents of torture may argue that in extreme circumstances, such as in the case of imminent terrorist attacks, the use of torture may be justified in order to extract vital information quickly.

From a utilitarian ethical perspective, the argument in support of torture may be framed in terms of the potential for the greater good. If the use of torture could potentially save many lives by preventing a terrorist attack, some may argue that the short-term suffering of the individual being tortured is outweighed by the long-term benefit to society.

On the other hand, the argument against torture is rooted in the belief that it is a violation of human rights and dignity. From a deontological ethical perspective, the use of torture is seen as inherently wrong because it treats individuals as mere means to an end, rather than as ends in themselves. It is argued that torture is a violation of the fundamental human right to be free from cruel and inhumane treatment.

Furthermore, opponents of torture may also argue that the use of torture is not only morally wrong, but also ineffective. There is evidence to suggest that individuals who are subjected to torture may provide false information in order to end their suffering, making the practice unreliable as a means of obtaining accurate information.

In conclusion, the argument in support of torture is often based on the potential for obtaining critical information in extreme circumstances, while the argument against it is rooted in the ethical principles of human rights and dignity, as well as the practical concerns about its effectiveness. Ultimately, the debate over the use of torture is a complex and contentious ethical issue that requires careful consideration of both the potential benefits and the ethical implications.

What Is the Argument in Support of Torture? What Is

Definitions: