Describe a Case in Which Utilitarianism Seems to Require That

question 8

Essay

Describe a case in which utilitarianism seems to require that someone behave unjustly. Do you think utilitarianism nonetheless gives the correct moral verdict in this case? Why or why not? How might a utilitarian reply to the objection that the theory wrongly licenses injustice?

---

Definitions:

Viable Alternative

A feasible or practical option that serves as a substitute or replacement for something else.

Conventional Viewpoint

A perspective or opinion that is widely accepted or regarded as standard, traditional, or typical within a given society or community.

Overwhelming

A feeling or situation so intense that it's hard to manage or endure.

Persistent and Unswerving Action

Continuous and unwavering effort towards achieving a specific goal, without being diverted by challenges or setbacks.