Do You Have to Be a Virtuous Person to Perform

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is According to Aristotle, a virtuous person is someone who consistently acts in accordance with virtue, and a virtuous action is one that is performed willingly and knowingly in accordance with virtue. However, Aristotle also acknowledges that it is possible for someone who lacks a particular virtue to perform a virtuous action.

Aristotle's account of how virtue is acquired does not necessarily present a problem in this regard. He believed that virtue is acquired through habituation and practice. By repeatedly performing virtuous actions, a person can develop virtuous habits and ultimately become a virtuous person. Therefore, even if someone lacks a particular virtue, they can still perform virtuous actions and, through practice, develop that virtue over time.

For example, someone who lacks courage may still be able to perform a courageous act in a specific situation. This could be due to external factors such as a sense of duty, a desire to protect others, or a willingness to face their fears in that particular moment. Over time, if they continue to act courageously in similar situations, they may develop the virtue of courage.

In conclusion, while it is ideal for a virtuous person to consistently act in accordance with virtue, it is still possible for someone who lacks a particular virtue to perform a virtuous action. This aligns with Aristotle's belief that virtue is acquired through habituation and practice, rather than being an inherent trait.

Do You Have to Be a Virtuous Person to Perform

Definitions: