Through Their Replies, It Is Clear That John Corvino Disagrees

question 8

Essay

Through their replies, it is clear that John Corvino disagrees with Ryan Anderson and Sherif Girgis on what must be involved in a discriminatory act for it to be harmful. In your essay, explain the nature of these authors' disagreement, drawing from both of their works. Then, offer an explanation of what type of discriminatory act is involved in a case like Bowman-Cryer's (that Corvino discusses in his essay). Do you think Corvino's or Anderson and Girgis' description of harm best fits this case? Why?

---

Definitions:

Home Market

The domestic marketplace where goods and services are bought and sold within a country.

Dumping

The practice of selling goods in a foreign market at a price that is below the cost of production or below the price in the home market, often considered an unfair trade practice.

Government Subsidies

Financial assistance provided by the government to individuals, organizations or industries to support or promote economic and social policies.

Budget Surplus

A situation where income or receipts exceed expenditures, typically within a government's budget.