Virginia Held: Feminist Transformations of Moral Theory

question 24

Essay

Virginia Held: Feminist Transformations of Moral Theory
Held argues that the history of moral philosophy is deeply infected by male bias, so much so that even the main concepts of the discipline reflect a lack of respect for women's experiences. In particular, Held discusses three broad ideas in moral philosophy that she finds particularly problematic from a feminist perspective. The first is the traditional conception of the relationship between reason and emotion. Many philosophers have held that reason should play a primary role in ethics, either by discovering universal moral principles, or impartially calculating the costs and benefits of various actions. Against this, Held argues for giving the emotions a prominent role in our moral lives, especially the emotions of care that accompany close relationships.
Second, Held criticizes the traditional interpretation of the distinction between the public and the private. On this conception, "the public realm is seen as the distinctively human realm in which man transcends his animal nature, while the private realm of the household is seen as the natural region in which women merely reproduce the species." Held objects to this conception, and argues that motherhood equally "transcends animal nature," especially insofar as it involves helping children to develop as moral beings. Held finds the relationship of care implicit in motherhood to be of particular moral importance, and regards traditional moral philosophy as deficient for neglecting it.
Finally, Held critiques the common conception of the self as a rational individual, independent and largely self-interested. She argues that close attention to the experiences of women yields a conception of the self as deeply enmeshed in particular relationships in which self-interest and altruism are no longer easy to distinguish. Given these three instances of male bias, Held argues, moral philosophy is in need of a radical transformation to take adequate account of the experiences of women.
-Explain Held's criticisms of atomistic views of the self. What does she think is mistaken about these conceptions, and what harm does she claim this causes? Do you agree with her? Why or why not?

---

Definitions:

Interpersonal Loneliness

A feeling of isolation or lack of connection experienced at the level of personal interactions and relationships.

Intimate Relationships

Deeply personal connections between individuals characterized by emotional closeness, love, trust, and mutual support.

Emotional Loneliness

A feeling of being emotionally disconnected from others, often resulting from the absence of intimate relationships.

Social Loneliness

The feeling of being isolated or not part of any social group, leading to feelings of sadness or loneliness because of a perceived lack of social connections.