Chalmers Argues for a Theory of Mind Known as "Property

question 4

True/False

Chalmers argues for a theory of mind known as "property dualism" (also "nonreductive materialism" and "naturalistic dualism"). In this view, mental states, or properties, are distinct from physical properties, and arise from the physical properties without being reducible to, or identical to, them (and without being some kind of Cartesian substance). Philosophers like to say that this relationship between the mental and physical is one of supervenience-that is, mental properties supervene on the physical ones. This means that something possesses a mental property in virtue of having a physical property. The mental property depends on the physical one, arises from it, but is not identical to it. If true, reductive materialism must be false. "This failure of materialism," says Chalmers, "leads to a kind of dualism: there are both physical and nonphysical features of the world." Mental properties are features of the world that are "over and above the physical features of the world."
-Block concedes that the argument based on the Chinese brain thought experiment is incoherent.

---

Definitions:

Backlash

A strong negative reaction or opposition arising in response to an action or decision.

Authenticity Risk

The possibility that a brand or product may lose its perception of genuineness or originiality in the eyes of consumers.

New Coke

A reformulation of Coca-Cola introduced in 1985, which was a major marketing failure and led to the return of the original formula as "Coca-Cola Classic."

Classical Recipe

A traditional set of instructions for making a specific dish, typically passed down through generations.