What Is Moral Luck, and Why Would the Existence of Moral

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Moral luck is the concept that an individual's moral character and actions are influenced by factors beyond their control, such as luck or external circumstances. This means that someone can be judged morally based on outcomes that were not entirely within their power to determine.

The existence of moral luck poses a problem for Kant's theory because Kant's moral philosophy is based on the idea that moral worth is determined by the intention behind an action, rather than the consequences. According to Kant, an action is only morally good if it is done out of a sense of duty and in accordance with the moral law, regardless of the outcome. However, the concept of moral luck suggests that individuals can be held morally responsible for outcomes that were beyond their control, which goes against Kant's emphasis on the importance of intention over consequences.

Whether or not moral luck exists is a matter of philosophical debate. Some argue that external factors can indeed influence the moral worth of an action, while others maintain that moral responsibility should be based solely on the individual's intentions and choices.

In my opinion, moral luck does exist to some extent. External circumstances can certainly impact the outcomes of our actions, and it seems unfair to hold individuals entirely responsible for factors beyond their control. However, I also believe that individuals still have a degree of agency and responsibility for their choices, and that intention should play a significant role in determining moral worth. Ultimately, the existence of moral luck highlights the complexity of moral judgment and the need for a nuanced approach to ethical decision-making.

What Is Moral Luck, and Why Would the Existence of Moral

Definitions: