What Is Resurrection? Describe and Evaluate Two Philosophical Objections to It

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Resurrection is the belief in some religious traditions that a person who has died will be brought back to life, either in a physical or spiritual form. This concept is often associated with the idea of an afterlife, where the resurrected individual will continue to exist in some form beyond death.

Two philosophical objections to the concept of resurrection are the problem of personal identity and the problem of the physical body.

The problem of personal identity raises the question of whether the resurrected individual would truly be the same person who died, or if they would be a completely different entity with the same memories and characteristics. This objection challenges the coherence of the concept of resurrection, as it is difficult to reconcile the idea of a person being brought back to life with the continuity of their personal identity.

The problem of the physical body questions the plausibility of a physical resurrection, particularly in light of the decomposition of the body after death. This objection raises concerns about the feasibility of reconstituting a physical body that has decayed or been destroyed, and whether such a resurrection could be considered a genuine restoration of the individual.

In evaluating these objections, it is important to consider the religious and metaphysical frameworks within which the concept of resurrection is understood. For believers, the objections may not hold the same weight as they do for non-believers, as the concept of resurrection is often grounded in faith and the supernatural. Additionally, different religious traditions have varying interpretations of resurrection, which may address or circumvent these philosophical objections in different ways.

Overall, the concept of resurrection raises complex philosophical questions about personal identity, the nature of the self, and the possibility of life after death. While these objections present significant challenges to the coherence and plausibility of resurrection, they also highlight the deep and enduring philosophical significance of this concept across different cultural and religious traditions.

What Is Resurrection? Describe and Evaluate Two Philosophical Objections to It

Definitions: