Roberts Leased a Duplex from Hughes

question 33

Essay

Roberts leased a duplex from Hughes. Later, without Hughes' knowledge, Roberts sublet half of the duplex to Carrera. Carrera did not take proper care of the premises and her part of the duplex was substantially damaged as a result of her negligent use and abuse. Upon discovering the situation, Hughes notified Roberts that he was holding him responsible for any and all damages to Carrera's portion of the duplex, and that Roberts was to bear the costs of returning the premises to the original state of repair. Roberts replied that he had sublet to Carrera in good faith, had no further dealings with Carrera after the sublet agreement, had no knowledge of negligence, and could not be held liable for damages caused by another. Can Roberts be held liable?

---

Definitions:

Moral Development

Refers to the process by which individuals learn to distinguish right from wrong and to develop attitudes and behaviors that are socially acceptable.

Ethical Behavior

Conduct that is consistent with agreed principles of moral and ethical standards, often involving honesty, integrity, fairness, and respect for others.

Social Norms

Unwritten rules or expectations for behavior within a social group, which shape individuals' actions and interactions.

Morally Justifiable

Actions or decisions that can be defended as right or acceptable according to ethical principles.