Consider This Comment from the Philosopher C

question 5

Multiple Choice

Consider this comment from the philosopher C.D.Broad regarding Kant's means-end principle: "If we isolate a man who is a carrier of typhoid,we are treating him merely as a cause of infection to others.But,if we refuse to isolate him,we are treating other people merely as means to his comfort and culture." This example suggests that:

• A)our duties not to use people merely as a means can conflict,and Kant provides no counsel on how to resolve such dilemmas.
• B)our duties not to use people merely as a means can sometimes be difficult to discern,but they never actually conflict.
• C)our duties not to use people merely as a means are imperfect duties.
• D)our duties are always clear upon further reflection.

---

Definitions:

Detachment

Extreme introversion.

Dependent Personality Disorder

A mental health condition characterized by a pervasive and excessive need to be taken care of, leading to submissive and clinging behavior and fears of separation.

Neuroticism

A personality trait characterized by emotional instability, anxiety, moodiness, and a tendency to experience negative emotions.

Agreeableness

A personality trait characterized by warmth, kindness, empathy, and a willingness to cooperate with others.