The Tragic Case of Andrea Yates Has Led to Discussions

question 78

Multiple Choice

The tragic case of Andrea Yates has led to discussions of mental disorders and personal responsibility. Our authors note that:

• A) the insanity defence needs to be broadened so that individuals suffering from psychological problems have a compassionate response from society.
• B) people who commit crimes need to face the consequences of their behaviour, but individuals suffering from psychological problems need the compassionate support of society.
• C) the "diminished responsibility" defence needs to replace the insanity defence in the case of individuals suffering from psychological problems.
• D) the insanity defence needs to be eliminated because it exonerates defendants who have committed crimes of violence.

---

Definitions:

Dynamic Conflict

A situation of opposition or struggle between forces that are active and capable of causing change.

Behavior Therapy

A type of psychotherapy that focuses on modifying negative behaviors and thought patterns.

Symptom Substitution

A hypothesis in some psychological schools of thought that a symptom will be replaced by another if the underlying cause of the symptom is not addressed.

Behavioral Activation

A therapy technique designed to help patients engage more in their lives through activities that are aligned with their values, to combat depression.