A Study by Charles and Mary Brown Has Documented a Reduction

question 41

Multiple Choice

A study by Charles and Mary Brown has documented a reduction in the wing length of cliff swallows that live near busy roadways; the study proposes that the need to avoid being hit by cars is the evolutionary driving force for the change.How would you evaluate this hypothesis if wing length had also shortened in cliff swallow populations that live in the desert Southwest where traffic is virtually nonexistent?

• A) The hypothesis would still be valid. Natural selection is driven by local conditions; the two populations are probably evolving independently and they have coincidentally acquired the same characteristics.
• B) The hypothesis would raise some doubts; perhaps aerial predators or another factor yet to be identified are creating the necessity for better flying skills in both populations.
• C) The hypothesis would not be valid, because the probability of the same wing length mutation arising in geographically distinct populations is extremely low.
• D) The hypothesis would not be valid; if the need to avoid vehicular collisions is driving natural selection, then no evolution should be occurring in the population that lives in the traffic-free environment.

---

Definitions:

Qualitative Reasoning

A method of reasoning that focuses on understanding qualities, attributes, and non-numeric aspects of phenomena.

Stage Theory

A theory of development organized into distinct stages, each characterized by specific abilities, experiences, or tasks that must be mastered.

Piaget Underestimated

A critique suggesting that the cognitive abilities of children can develop earlier than Jean Piaget, a Swiss psychologist, proposed in his theories.

Senior Citizen

A senior citizen is an older adult, typically someone who has reached the age of retirement, which varies by country but is often around 60-65 years of age.