Use This Information for Questions That Refer to the United

question 189

Multiple Choice

Use this information for questions that refer to the United Tools case. Terry Harter is marketing manager for United Tools,and Mike O'Reilly is the firm's logistics manager.They work together to make decisions about how to get United's hand and power tools to its customers-a mix of manufacturing plants and final consumers (who buy United tools at a hardware store) .United Tools does not own its own transport facilities,and it works with wholesalers to reach its business customers.
Together,Harter and O'Reilly try to coordinate transporting,storing,and product-handling activities to minimize cost while still achieving the customer service level their customers and intermediaries want.This usually requires that United keep an inventory of most of its products on hand; but demand for its products is fairly consistent over time,so inventory is easy to manage.
Harter has identified four options for physical distribution systems she could use to reach two of her key wholesalers,Ralston Supply and Ricotta Tool Co.The total cost for each option-and the distribution service levels that can be achieved-are as follows:
$\begin{array}{c}\begin{array}{lll}\\1.\\2.\\3.\\4.\\\\\end{array}\begin{array}{lll}\text{Main feature of system:}\\Airfreight\\Inland ~waterways\\Trucks\\Rail ~and ~regional\\warehouses\\\end{array}\begin{array}{lll}\begin{array}{rc}\text { Total Cost}&\text { Distribution Service Level }\\\$ 1,000,000 & 95 \text { percent } \\\$ 300,000 & 60 \text { percent } \\\$ 500,000 & 70 \text { percent } \\\$ 650,000 & 80 \text { percent }\\\\\end{array}\end{array}\end{array}$
Ralston Supply expects a very high level (90 percent) of distribution customer service.Ricotta Tool Co.is willing to settle for a 70 percent customer service -leveleven if that means some products will occasionally be out of -stockif it gets products at a lower price.
For its large retail hardware customers (like Home Depot) ,United regularly ships smaller orders directly to individual stores or in some cases to the retail chain's warehouses.Cross-country shipments usually go by rail,while regional shipments usually go by truck.
Which physical distribution system is best suited for Ralston Supply?

• A)airfreight
• B)inland waterways
• C)truck
• D)rail and warehouse
• E)This cannot be determined without more information.

---

Definitions:

Investment Project

A project involving the allocation of capital resources with the expectation of generating future returns or benefits.

Discount Factor

A multiplier for future cash flows to convert them into present value, reflecting the time value of money.

Contribution Margin

The amount remaining from sales revenue after variable costs are deducted, indicating how much revenue is contributing to fixed costs and profit.

Incremental Annual Net Cash Inflows

The additional cash that flows into a business on an annual basis as a result of a specific action or investment.