Why Might Managers Be Tempted to Violate the Revenue Principle

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Managers might be tempted to violate the revenue principle and the matching principle when preparing an income statement for several reasons, often related to the pressures of financial reporting, performance metrics, and personal incentives. Here's a closer look at each principle and the reasons for potential violations:

1. **Revenue Principle**: The revenue principle, also known as the revenue recognition principle, dictates that revenue should be recognized in the accounting period in which it is earned and realizable, regardless of when the cash is actually received. This principle ensures that the income statement reflects the true income generated by the company during a specific period.

**Reasons for Violation**:
- **Meeting Earnings Targets**: Managers may be under pressure to meet or exceed quarterly or annual earnings projections to satisfy investor expectations or to trigger performance bonuses.
- **Stock Price Concerns**: Publicly traded companies are often judged by their ability to grow revenue. Managers might prematurely recognize revenue to paint a more favorable picture of the company's financial health, potentially influencing the stock price.
- **Banking Covenants**: Companies may need to show certain financial metrics to comply with banking covenants. Recognizing revenue earlier can help meet these requirements.

2. **Matching Principle**: The matching principle requires that expenses be matched to the revenues they helped to generate in the same accounting period. This principle is fundamental to accrual accounting and ensures that the income statement accurately reflects the company's profitability.

**Reasons for Violation**:
- **Smoothing Earnings**: Managers might delay recording expenses to show higher profits in the short term, a practice known as "earnings smoothing." This can make a company appear more stable and profitable than it actually is.
- **Bonus Schemes**: If managerial bonuses are tied to profit levels, there may be an incentive to defer expenses to inflate profits artificially.
- **Managing Expectations**: By manipulating the timing of expense recognition, managers can manage external expectations and potentially influence the market's perception of the company's performance.

Both principles are fundamental to the accrual basis of accounting, which aims to provide a more accurate picture of a company's financial position and performance than the cash basis of accounting. However, the temptation to violate these principles can be strong, especially when managers face short-term pressures and incentives that conflict with the principles' long-term focus on financial integrity and accuracy.

It's important to note that violating these principles can lead to serious consequences, including regulatory penalties, loss of investor trust, and damage to the company's reputation. Moreover, such actions can be considered fraudulent and lead to legal action against the company and the individuals involved. Therefore, while there may be temptations to violate these principles, upholding them is crucial for maintaining ethical standards and ensuring the reliability of financial reporting.

Why Might Managers Be Tempted to Violate the Revenue Principle

Definitions: