Critically Discuss the Following Analogical Argument

question 137

Essay

Critically discuss the following analogical argument:
Economic sanctions simply do not work. As a weapon of international persuasion, they are about as effective as popguns.
The United Nations imposed drastic sanctions upon Rhodesia; they failed utterly.
We imposed sanctions upon Poland; nothing happened.
Our government has forbidden trade with Cuba for the past twenty-five years; Cuba goes its own way.
Most recently, the president has laid heavy sanctions upon Libya; our noble allies have pooh-poohed the effort.
You can count on the same kind of result if economic sanctions are imposed on North Korea.

---

Definitions:

Tasks

Specific duties or activities assigned to individuals or teams as part of their roles or projects.

People

Human beings, individually or collectively, considered in a social, professional, or personal context.

Trait Theories

Psychological perspectives that suggest individual behaviors, motivations, and personalities are conditioned by inherent traits.

Effective Leaders

Leaders who achieve desired outcomes through their influence and guidance, often by inspiring and motivating others.