Compare Between-Subjects and Within-Subjects Designs and Explain the Control Problems

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Between-subjects and within-subjects designs are two different types of experimental designs used in research studies.

Between-subjects design involves comparing different groups of participants, with each group exposed to a different experimental condition. For example, one group might receive a new treatment, while another group receives a placebo. The key advantage of between-subjects design is that it allows researchers to control for individual differences between participants. However, this design also presents unique control problems, such as ensuring that the groups are equivalent at the start of the study and that any differences in the outcomes can be attributed to the experimental manipulation rather than pre-existing differences between the groups.

On the other hand, within-subjects design involves exposing the same group of participants to multiple experimental conditions. For example, participants might be asked to perform a task under different conditions, such as with and without a distraction. The advantage of within-subjects design is that it allows researchers to control for individual differences by using the same participants in all conditions. However, this design also presents unique control problems, such as the potential for carryover effects, where exposure to one condition influences performance in subsequent conditions, and the need to counterbalance the order of conditions to control for order effects.

In summary, between-subjects and within-subjects designs both have their own advantages and control problems. Researchers need to carefully consider these factors when designing their studies and interpreting the results.

Compare Between-Subjects and Within-Subjects Designs and Explain the Control Problems

Definitions: