When People Observe Their Own Behavior, Sometimes They Infer Dispositions

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The type of attribution people make about themselves—whether they infer dispositions (internal attributions) or implicate the situation (external attributions)—is influenced by several factors. Understanding these factors can help explain why people interpret their own behavior in different ways under different circumstances. Here are some key influences:

1. **Consistency**: If a behavior is consistent over time, people are more likely to make a dispositional attribution. For example, if someone always gets nervous before public speaking, they might conclude that they are a nervous person.

2. **Distinctiveness**: If a behavior is unique to a particular situation, people are more likely to make a situational attribution. For instance, if someone only gets angry when they are in traffic, they might attribute their anger to the situation (heavy traffic) rather than to an internal disposition (being an angry person).

3. **Consensus**: If other people are behaving in the same way in the same situation, individuals are more likely to make a situational attribution. For example, if everyone in a class fails a test, a student is likely to blame the difficulty of the test rather than their own ability.

4. **Cognitive Processes**: Self-serving bias is a cognitive process where individuals attribute their successes to internal factors and their failures to external factors. This bias helps maintain self-esteem.

5. **Culture**: Individualistic cultures, which emphasize personal achievement and autonomy, are more likely to make dispositional attributions. In contrast, collectivistic cultures, which emphasize group harmony and interdependence, are more likely to make situational attributions.

6. **Motivation and Emotion**: People's current needs, goals, and emotions can influence their attributions. For example, if someone is motivated to see themselves in a positive light, they might attribute their good deeds to their character and their mistakes to the situation.

7. **Perceptual Salience**: The focus of a person's attention at the time of the behavior can influence attribution. If the individual is highly aware of the situational factors, they may be more likely to attribute their behavior to the situation.

8. **Past Experiences and Knowledge**: Personal history and learned knowledge can shape how people interpret their behavior. If someone has learned that their mood is affected by the weather, they might attribute a bad mood to a rainy day.

9. **Social and Environmental Cues**: Feedback from others and environmental cues can also influence self-attribution. For example, if others praise someone for being helpful in a situation, the person may be more likely to attribute that behavior to their own disposition.

10. **Psychological State**: Mental health and cognitive biases can affect self-attribution. For instance, individuals with depression may be more likely to attribute failures to internal, stable, and global factors due to a cognitive style known as depressive attributional style.

In summary, the attributions people make about their own behavior are complex and influenced by a variety of factors, including the context of the behavior, cultural norms, cognitive biases, and personal motivations. Understanding these factors can provide insight into why people sometimes see their actions as a reflection of their character and other times as a response to the situation.

When People Observe Their Own Behavior, Sometimes They Infer Dispositions

Definitions: