CW, Inc Publishes Consumer Watchdog, a Magazine Whose Articles Consist of of the Writers

question 25

Essay

CW, Inc. publishes Consumer Watchdog, a magazine whose articles consist of the writers' personal experiences with and reactions to a variety of products. In the June 1997 issue of Consumer Watchdog, a review included this statement: "Fungus Co.'s "Fungo" brand athlete's foot powder doesn't cut the mustard in comparison to most athlete's foot powders on the market--and I've tried them all, sports fans. Fungo fails to attack athlete's foot with enough force because the product doesn't contain AF88, the active ingredient in any decent athlete's foot powder." In fact, Fungo contains as much AF88 as any other athlete's foot powder on the market. Fungus Co. has filed suit against the writer and CW on the theory that the above statements violated section 43(a) of the Lanham Act. On these facts, should Fungus win the section 43(a) case? Why or why not?

---

Definitions:

Apples

Edible fruits from the apple tree, known for their sweet taste and crunchy texture, and used in a variety of culinary dishes.

Bananas

A type of fruit that is elongated, curved, and covered with a peel, typically yellow when ripe, and consumed as a sweet source of energy.

Perfect Substitute

Goods that can be used in place of one another with no loss of utility for the consumer, indicating a one-to-one substitutability.

Utility Function

A mathematical representation that assigns a level of utility or satisfaction to different bundles of goods, allowing preferences to be compared quantitatively.