A Newspaper Runs a Column on the Editorial Page Once

question 4

Essay

A newspaper runs a column on the editorial page once a week written by Julie James.The column is entitled "My Opinion." One week,James writes a column about animals,such as cats and dogs,being stolen from people's yards and being sold to medical and cosmetic testing laboratories.The column includes information from police reports and statements from some people whose animals were stolen.The columnist makes clear that she thinks stealing animals for experimental purposes is a terrible thing to do.Then the column says,"Sam Jones,a deputy sheriff in Adams County,has received some of these animals and sold them to George Smith.Smith,in turn,sold them to the testing labs.While it is unclear whether Jones knew the animals were stolen,he knew that he was being a rotten and repulsive person,and dealing with people who-like himself-are among the lowest of the low." Jones brings suit for libel based on the words "rotten," "repulsive," and "lowest of the low." Assuming Jones can prove all the elements of the plaintiff's case,what is the newspaper's (and columnist's)one best defense? Will it be a successful defense? Why or why not?

---

Definitions:

Categorical Imperative

The moral principle proposed by Immanuel Kant that actions are morally right only if they can be universally applied as a general rule for behavior.

Categorical Imperative

A concept developed by the philosopher Immanuel Kant as a way of evaluating motivations for action, stating that an action is morally right if it can be universally applied to everyone without contradiction.

Immanuel Kant

A German philosopher renowned for his work on the theory of ethics, particularly the concept of the categorical imperative, which asserts that actions are morally right if they can be universally applied.

Moral Stages

Describes the progression of moral reasoning and ethical behavior in humans, often conceptualized as a sequential development through specific stages.