What Is the Difference Between "Formal" and "Substantive" Rationality

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Formal rationality refers to the process of decision-making based on logical reasoning and adherence to established rules and procedures. It focuses on the consistency and coherence of the decision-making process, regardless of the actual outcome. In other words, a formally rational decision is one that is made using a systematic and logical approach, without necessarily considering the practical or real-world implications.

On the other hand, substantive rationality takes into account the actual content and consequences of a decision. It considers the goals, values, and objectives that are being pursued, and evaluates the decision based on its ability to achieve those ends. Substantive rationality is concerned with the practical effectiveness and desirability of a decision, rather than just its formal logic.

In summary, the difference between formal and substantive rationality lies in the focus of the decision-making process. Formal rationality emphasizes the logical and procedural aspects of decision-making, while substantive rationality considers the actual content and outcomes of the decision. Both are important in different contexts, and a truly rational decision-making process should ideally incorporate elements of both formal and substantive rationality.

What Is the Difference Between "Formal" and "Substantive" Rationality

Definitions: