McPhee's Approach to Communicative Constitution of Organizations Is Criticized by Others

question 5

Essay

McPhee's approach to communicative constitution of organizations is criticized by others who hold similar perspectives, such as James Taylor from the University of Toronto. Rather than subscribing to what he calls McPhee's top-down approach to organizational constitution, Taylor favors alternative perspective. Describe Taylor's approach and then state your own informed opinion about which of the two is most reasonable to you. Support your claim with evidence.

---

Definitions:

Hostility

Feelings of intense anger or aggression towards others, which can manifest in antagonistic actions or thoughts.

Health Risk

The probability of suffering harm from any cause, typically expressed in terms of physical or psychological health.

Psychosocial Factors

Elements that involve both psychological and social aspects, affecting mental health and wellbeing, including interpersonal relationships and coping strategies.

Physical Disease

Any condition that causes the body's systems to not function properly, often leading to symptoms and health challenges.