Russ Shafer-Landau Is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Wisconsin-Madison

question 12

True/False

Russ Shafer-Landau is professor of philosophy at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. He is the author, editor, or coeditor of several books including The Fundamentals of Ethics, fourth edition (2017) and The Ethical Life, fourth edition (2017). He is also the editor of Oxford Studies in Metaethics. In this reading he reviews some common criticisms of utilitarianism and argues that although some of them are less than decisive, others pose serious problems for the theory. Utilitarianism's most crippling shortcomings are its insistence that there is no intrinsic wrongness (or rightness) and its requirement that we must maximize well-being even if justice is thwarted.
-Some utilitarians concede that well-being and justice sometimes conflict, but when they do, it is justice and not well-being that must take a backseat.

---

Definitions:

Adopted Children

Children who have been legally taken by individuals or couples to be cared for as their own.

Identical Twins

Twins who develop from a single fertilized egg that splits and forms two embryos, sharing 100% of their DNA.

Nonidentical Twins

Twins born from two separate eggs fertilized at the same time, leading to siblings that share genetic similarities but are not genetically identical.

Biological Siblings

Siblings who share the same biological parents, fully related genetically.