Thomas Nagel Is Professor of Philosophy at New York University

question 8

Multiple Choice

Thomas Nagel is professor of philosophy at New York University and the author of several works in moral and political philosophy. In this selection Nagel challenges the Kantian way of viewing morality, which assumes that we are all equal rational participants in the moral enterprise, each having the same opportunity to be moral. Nagel suggests that this view is simplistic and fails to take into account the manner in which external factors impinge upon us. They introduce the idea of moral luck, which he defines thus: "Where a significant aspect of what someone does depends on factors beyond his control, yet we continue to treat him in that respect as an object of moral judgment, it can be called moral luck."
Four types of moral luck are considered: constitutive luck, circumstantial luck, consequential luck in which consequences retrospectively justify an otherwise immoral act (or fail to justify an otherwise moral act) , and consequential luck in which the consequences affect the type of blame or remorse (or moral praise) .
-Nagel says that our "prior to reflection" intuition is that people cannot be

• A) the victim of luck.
• B) morally assessed for what is not their fault.
• C) guilty.
• D) lucky.

---

Definitions:

Clean Water Act

U.S. federal law established to regulate pollutant discharges into the waters of the United States and to set water quality standards.

Toxic Chemicals

Substances that can cause harm to humans, animals, plants, or the environment when they are released or their concentration exceeds certain levels.

Water Supply

The provision and management of water resources for consumption, sanitation, and various uses.

Clean Water Act

The Clean Water Act is a federal law enacted in the United States aimed at reducing pollution and protecting the quality of the nation's waters, including lakes, rivers, and coastal areas.