Propose a Case, Real or Imaginary, in Which the Health

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is One potential case where the obligation of justice conflicts with the obligation of beneficence for health care providers is in the allocation of scarce medical resources. For example, imagine a hospital with a limited number of ventilators during a pandemic. The health care providers have a duty to provide the best possible care for their patients, which aligns with the principle of beneficence. However, they also have a duty to distribute resources fairly and justly, which aligns with the principle of justice.

In this scenario, the health care providers may face a conflict between providing potentially life-saving treatment to one patient in need of a ventilator, while denying that treatment to another patient who is also in critical condition. This creates a moral dilemma for the providers, as they must balance the individual benefit of one patient with the overall fairness and equity of resource allocation.

Given the discussion in Chapter 18, the health care providers should prioritize the principle of justice in this situation. They should follow established guidelines and ethical frameworks for allocating scarce resources, such as using a transparent and fair triage system that considers factors like likelihood of survival and potential years of life saved. By prioritizing justice in resource allocation, the providers can ensure that their decisions are based on ethical principles and the greatest good for the greatest number of patients, even if it means making difficult choices about individual patient care. Additionally, they should advocate for increased resources and support from governing bodies to prevent future conflicts between beneficence and justice in healthcare delivery.

Propose a Case, Real or Imaginary, in Which the Health

Definitions: