In the Facts of the Previous Question,under the Reasoning of the Dissent

question 9

Multiple Choice

In the facts of the previous question,under the reasoning of the dissent in Batte-Holmgren v.Commissioner of Public Health,the court hearing Jett's suit should

• A)overturn the ban because private clubs are not open to the public.
• B)overturn the ban because there is no rational relationship between the ban's purpose and the exemption for private clubs.
• C)uphold the ban because protecting employees from secondhand smoke is a legitimate state purpose.
• D)uphold the ban because private clubs are not open to the public.

---

Definitions:

Eosinophil

A type of white blood cell involved in the immune response, especially in fighting certain infections and in allergic reactions.

Parasitic

Pertaining to organisms that live on or in a host organism and may cause harm by deriving nutrients at the host's expense.

Shearing

The action or process of applying a force that causes different layers of a material to slide past each other, often related to skin and tissue injuries.

Unlicensed Assistive Personnel

Individuals who provide basic care services under the supervision of licensed healthcare professionals, without having a professional license themselves.