Describe the Higher-Brain Theory of Death

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is The higher-brain theory of death posits that an individual is considered dead when there is irreversible loss of functioning in the higher brain, which includes the cerebral cortex. This theory focuses on the cessation of consciousness, self-awareness, and the ability to interact with the environment as the defining criteria for death.

Two alternative views of personhood, human identity, human being, or moral status are the biological view and the relational view. The biological view emphasizes the importance of biological processes and characteristics in defining personhood and human identity. This view often considers the presence of a functioning brain or a certain level of cognitive ability as essential for personhood. On the other hand, the relational view emphasizes the significance of social relationships, connections, and interactions in shaping personhood and human identity. This view suggests that our relationships with others and our impact on the world around us are crucial aspects of what it means to be a person.

When comparing and contrasting these views, it becomes evident that the higher-brain theory of death aligns closely with the biological view, as both emphasize the importance of cognitive functioning and consciousness in defining personhood and death. However, the relational view offers a different perspective by highlighting the significance of social connections and relationships in shaping our identity and moral status.

In evaluating these views, it is important to consider the complexities of human existence and the diverse ways in which individuals experience personhood. While the higher-brain theory of death and the biological view provide a clear and measurable criteria for defining death and personhood, they may overlook the broader aspects of human identity and moral status that are emphasized in the relational view. Ultimately, the most satisfactory view may be one that integrates elements of all three perspectives, recognizing the importance of cognitive functioning, social relationships, and individual experiences in defining personhood and moral status. This integrated approach would provide a more comprehensive understanding of what it means to be human and when death occurs.

Describe the Higher-Brain Theory of Death

Definitions: